I watched the
Kiera Knightly "Pride and Prejudice" last night. Or rather, tried. I will grant the following:
It was a treat to look at.
Kiera Knightly is adorable.
But she's no Elizabeth Bennett.
And I don't even know who that guy is who is supposed to be Mr. Darcy and won't even
IMDb him because I don't care.
Pft.
I fell asleep. There's the truth of it.
I might turn it back on this afternoon, do some ironing and see if the last half changes my mind. But I'm sceptical.
I have a point.
For quite some time now I have been saying "
pft" and "
meh" in response to this newest version of one of my very favorite books ever. These dismissive interjections have been made for the simple reason that, having seen the A&E production, it was clear no one would ever have to try and make the story again. It was a faithful rendering of the tale. Because it was a mini-series the script was deep and wide, with lots of characters and significant conversations that went to the heart of the principals and their motivations. It was pretty to look at, well acted and hello? starred Colin Firth as Mr. Darcy.
When the latest movie version was released in 2005 I never considered seeing it, citing the attempt as silly and futile. "Not interested.
Pft, again", I would say.
But there are people, people I like and respect, who over the years have said, "Oh, but you should see it. For what it is, it's quite well done". And then they'd go on to celebrate the performance of this person or that and talk about how gorgeous it was and such like that.
And I realized I was doing something I really hate in others: deciding ahead of the evidence. This is not the conduct of an intelligent, fair-minded person. Such a person bases her response to facts and research, not to blithe, unthinking reaction. Yes. I love Colin Firth. True, I believe him to be the
definitive Mr. Darcy. But to dismiss something out of hand, without even an attempt at understanding it, is silly, lazy and possibly even dangerous. (
Ok, not strictly in this context but as a rule knee-jerk
reactionism is most decidedly not a good thing. I could name one or two political movements that embody this. I won't. Just saying).
So I finally put the movie on my
Netflix list and then finally stopped shoving it back down the
queue every time it bubbled near the top. And after having it in my house for 2 weeks, finally watched it. And fell asleep. Because it really didn't do anything for me.
But at least now when I say, "Oh, I didn't care for it; I much prefer the A&E version", I won't be just talking out of the side of my neck. I'm fair-minded like that.
Labels: movies